The problem is people are stupid

| 2 Comments | No TrackBacks

I've really tried to avoid attributing the election results to the fact that the American people are basically just dumb as posts. I've rationalized that it was fear-based, or simply that people will vote against their best interests based on a candiates espousal of "moral values" regardless of their actions. But no - turns out that people are just stupid.

The following is stolen from Salon, but I don't feel too bad about the snatch, because they are basically reporting on someone else's reporting. So I say that I am doing the same...

"Chris Hayes first person report on undecided voters, published yesterday on The New Republic Online, is fascinating not just for what it says about the recent race, but for what it tells us about our polity.

After seven weeks canvassing swing voters in Wisconsin, Hayes concludes that the pundits' contempt for undecided voters is misplaced. It's not that they're undeserving of derision, he writes. It's "just that Jonah Goldberg, and the rest of us, may well be deriding them for the wrong reasons."

Hayes portrays undecided voters as so fatalistic that Bush's manifold failures only confirm their conviction that the world's problems are intractable, a conviction that worked against Kerry's promises to fix things. He paints them as weirdly irrational, possessed of chimerical "facts," and unable to connect to politics to material outcomes.

"Members of the political class may disparage undecided voters, but we at least tend to impute to them a basic rationality," Hayes writes. "We're giving them too much credit. I met voters who told me they were voting for Bush, but who named their most important issue as the environment. One man told me he voted for Bush in 2000 because he thought that with Cheney, an oilman, on the ticket, the administration would finally be able to make us independent from foreign oil…Then there was the woman who called our office a few weeks before the election to tell us that though she had signed up to volunteer for Kerry she had now decided to back Bush. Why? Because the president supported stem cell research."

More disturbing still is Hayes's portrayal of the odd lacuna in voters' understanding of what a political issue even is. "As far as I could tell, the problem wasn't the word 'issue'; it was a fundamental lack of understanding of what constituted the broad category of the 'political,' he writes. "The undecideds I spoke to didn't seem to have any intuitive grasp of what kinds of grievances qualify as political grievances. Often, once I would engage undecided voters, they would list concerns, such as the rising cost of health care; but when I would tell them that Kerry had a plan to lower health-care premiums, they would respond in disbelief -- not in disbelief that he had a plan, but that the cost of health care was a political issue. It was as if you were telling them that Kerry was promising to extend summer into December."

The depressing upshot of this is that Democrats can't make headway by configuring their policies. In the end, Hayes sees only two options: "either abandon 'issues' as the lynchpin of political campaigns and adopt the language of values, morals, and character as many have suggested; or begin the long-term and arduous task of rebuilding a popular, accessible political vocabulary -- of convincing undecided voters to believe once again in the importance of issues." In other words, find a demagogue or educate the country -- either way, Democrats have their work cut out for them."

So, basically people who are voting really have no idea what they are even voting for - they assign candiate positions that are the opposite of those the candiate espouses, and completely ignore facts. Okay, I admit it now. Most Americans are, in fact, stupid.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:


GWB steals an election, starts an endless war that enriches his pals, and gets re-elected. Yep, a nation of propagandised morons, how could you doubt it.

However I'm writing because you wanted details of 'Map of Dreams' but didn't provide a contact email address.

Map of Dreams was a 5-part fantasy based on a love story. It starred Mischa Bergese, the wolf in 'Company of Wolves' and an Indian singer and dancer.

The part showed different aspects of the people involved - dancer (Space space idla space) cutup newsreader (if/get/can/about/item) and politician (These people live on cushions etc.)

It was jolly good stuff with lots of video overlay, scrolling hex dumps and surreal touches. However at one point it showed a naked woman covered in clay, so the chances of seeing it on US TV are pretty slim.

All the best


Ha, I've known that for years.

Leave a comment

OpenID accepted here Learn more about OpenID
Powered by Movable Type 5.04

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by edgore published on November 18, 2004 11:31 AM.

It just gets better was the previous entry in this blog.

Someone to Watch Over Me is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.